Research Papers

Online Real-Time Quality Monitoring in Additive Manufacturing Processes Using Heterogeneous Sensors

[+] Author and Article Information
Prahalad K. Rao

Department of Systems Science and
Industrial Engineering,
State University of New York at Binghamton,
Binghamton, NY 13702

Jia (Peter) Liu

Grado Department of Industrial and
Systems Engineering,
Virginia Polytechnic Institute and
State University,
Blacksburg, VA 24061

David Roberson

Grado Department of Industrial and
Systems Engineering,
Virginia Polytechnic Institute and
State University,
Blacksburg, VA 24061

Zhenyu (James) Kong

Grado Department of Industrial and
Systems Engineering,
Virginia Polytechnic Institute and
State University,
Blacksburg, VA 24061
e-mail: zkong@vt.edu

Christopher Williams

Department of Mechanical Engineering,
Virginia Polytechnic Institute and
State University,
Blacksburg, VA 24061

1Corresponding author.

Contributed by the Manufacturing Engineering Division of ASME for publication in the JOURNAL OF MANUFACTURING SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING. Manuscript received September 17, 2014; final manuscript received February 6, 2015; published online September 9, 2015. Assoc. Editor: Robert Gao.

J. Manuf. Sci. Eng 137(6), 061007 (Sep 09, 2015) (12 pages) Paper No: MANU-14-1480; doi: 10.1115/1.4029823 History: Received September 17, 2014

The objective of this work is to identify failure modes and detect the onset of process anomalies in additive manufacturing (AM) processes, specifically focusing on fused filament fabrication (FFF). We accomplish this objective using advanced Bayesian nonparametric analysis of in situ heterogeneous sensor data. Experiments are conducted on a desktop FFF machine instrumented with a heterogeneous sensor array including thermocouples, accelerometers, an infrared (IR) temperature sensor, and a real-time miniature video borescope. FFF process failures are detected online using the nonparametric Bayesian Dirichlet process (DP) mixture model and evidence theory (ET) based on the experimentally acquired sensor data. This sensor data-driven defect detection approach facilitates real-time identification and correction of FFF process drifts with an accuracy and precision approaching 85% (average F-score). In comparison, the F-score from existing approaches, such as probabilistic neural networks (PNN), naïve Bayesian clustering, support vector machines (SVM), and quadratic discriminant analysis (QDA), was in the range of 55–75%.

Copyright © 2015 by ASME
Your Session has timed out. Please sign back in to continue.


Gibson, I. , Rosen, D. W. , and Stucker, B. , 2010, Additive Manufacturing Technologies: Rapid Prototyping to Direct Digital Manufacturing, Springer, New York.
Bourell, D. , Beaman, J. , Leu, M. , and Rosen, D. , 2009, “A Brief History of Additive Manufacturing and the Roadmap for Additive Manufacturing: Looking Back and Looking Ahead,” U.S.–Turkey Workshop on Rapid Technologies, pp. 5–11.
Kruth, J.-P. , Leu, M. , and Nakagawa, T. , 1998, “Progress in Additive Manufacturing and Rapid Prototyping,” CIRP Ann.-Manuf. Technol., 47(2), pp. 525–540. [CrossRef]
Levy, G. N. , Schindel, R. , and Kruth, J.-P. , 2003, “Rapid Manufacturing and Rapid Tooling With Layer Manufacturing (LM) Technologies, State of the Art and Future Perspectives,” CIRP Ann.-Manuf. Technol., 52(2), pp. 589–609. [CrossRef]
Turner, B. N. , Strong, R. , and Gold, S. A. , 2014, “A Review of Melt Extrusion Additive Manufacturing Processes: I. Process Design and Modeling,” Rapid Prototyping J., 20(3), pp. 192–204. [CrossRef]
Beyer, C. , 2014, “Strategic Implications of Current Trends in Additive Manufacturing,” ASME J. Manuf. Sci. Eng., 136(6), p. 064701. [CrossRef]
Khoshnevis, B. , Hwang, D. , Yao, K.-T. , and Yeh, Z. , 2006, “Mega-Scale Fabrication by Contour Crafting,” Int. J. Ind. Syst. Eng., 1(3), pp. 301–320.
Khoshnevis, B. , Bodiford, M. P. , Burks, K. H. , Ethridge, E. , Tucker, D. , Kim, W. , Toutanji, H. , and Fiske, M. R. , 2014, “Lunar Contour Crafting–A Novel Technique for ISRU Based Habitat Development,” American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics Conference, Reno, NV, pp. 1–13.
Cooper, K. P. , 2002, “Layered Manufacturing: Challenges and Opportunities,” Materials Research Society Symposia, Fall 2002 Meeting, Vol. 758, pp. 23–34.
Scott, J. , Gupta, N. , Weber, C. L. , Newsome, S. , Wohlers, T. , and Caffrey, T. , 2012, Additive Manufacturing: Status and Opportunities, Science and Technology Policy Institute, Washington, DC, pp. 1–29.
2013, Roundtable Forum on Additive Manufacturing: Opportunities and Constraints, Royal Academy of Engineering, London, UK.
Huang, Y. , Leu, M. C. , Mazumder, J. , and Donmez, A. , 2015, “Additive Manufacturing: Current State, Future Potential, Gaps and Needs, and Recommendations,” ASME J. Manuf. Sci. Eng., 137(1), p. 014001. [CrossRef]
Tapia, G. , and Elwany, A. , 2014, “A Review on Process Monitoring and Control in Metal-Based Additive Manufacturing,” ASME J. Manuf. Sci. Eng., 136(6), p. 060801. [CrossRef]
Huang, Q. , Nouri, H. , Xu, K. , Chen, Y. , Sosina, S. , and Dasgupta, T. , 2014, “Statistical Predictive Modeling and Compensation of Geometric Deviations of Three-Dimensional Printed Products,” ASME J. Manuf. Sci. Eng., 136(6), p. 061008. [CrossRef]
Energetics Incorporated, 2013, Measurement Science Roadmap for Metal-Based Additive Manufacturing, National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, MD.
Mahesh, M. , Wong, Y. , Fuh, J. , and Loh, H. , 2004, “Benchmarking for Comparative Evaluation of RP Systems and Processes,” Rapid Prototyping J., 10(2), pp. 123–135. [CrossRef]
Peng, A. H. , and Wang, Z. M. , 2010, “Researches Into Influence of Process Parameters on FDM Parts Precision,” Appl. Mech. Mater., 34, pp. 338–343. [CrossRef]
Wang, T.-M. , Xi, J.-T. , and Jin, Y. , 2007, “A Model Research for Prototype Warp Deformation in the FDM Process,” Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol., 33(11–12), pp. 1087–1096. [CrossRef]
Anitha, R. , Arunachalam, S. , and Radhakrishnan, P. , 2001, “Critical Parameters Influencing the Quality of Prototypes in Fused Deposition Modelling,” J. Mater. Process. Technol., 118(1–3), pp. 385–388. [CrossRef]
Armillotta, A. , 2006, “Assessment of Surface Quality on Textured FDM Prototypes,” Rapid Prototyping J., 12(1), pp. 35–41. [CrossRef]
Agarwala, M. K. , Jamalabad, V. R. , Langrana, N. A. , Safari, A. , Whalen, P. J. , and Danforth, S. C. , 1996, “Structural Quality of Parts Processed by Fused Deposition,” Rapid Prototyping J., 2(4), pp. 4–19. [CrossRef]
Pei, E. , Campbell, R. I. , and de Beer, D. , 2011, “Entry-Level RP Machines: How Well Can They Cope With Geometric Complexity?,” Assem. Autom., 31(2), pp. 153–160. [CrossRef]
Tong, K. , Joshi, S. , and Lehtihet, E. A. , 2008, “Error Compensation for Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM) Machine by Correcting Slice Files,” Rapid Prototyping J., 14(1), pp. 4–14. [CrossRef]
Qiu, D. , and Langrana, N. A. , 2002, “Void Eliminating Toolpath for Extrusion-Based Multi-Material Layered Manufacturing,” Rapid Prototyping J., 8(1), pp. 38–45. [CrossRef]
Lin, F. , Sun, W. , and Yan, Y. , 2001, “Optimization With Minimum Process Error for Layered Manufacturing Fabrication,” Rapid Prototyping J., 7(2), pp. 73–82. [CrossRef]
Xu, F. , Loh, H. , and Wong, Y. , 1999, “Considerations and Selection of Optimal Orientation for Different Rapid Prototyping Systems,” Rapid Prototyping J., 5(2), pp. 54–60. [CrossRef]
Hossain, M. S. , Espalin, D. , Ramos, J. , Perez, M. , and Wicker, R. , 2014, “Improved Mechanical Properties of Fused Deposition Modeling-Manufactured Parts Through Build Parameter Modifications,” ASME J. Manuf. Sci. Eng., 136(6), p. 061002. [CrossRef]
Sabourin, E. , Houser, S. A. , and Bøhn, J. H. , 1997, “Accurate Exterior, Fast Interior Layered Manufacturing,” Rapid Prototyping J., 3(2), pp. 44–52. [CrossRef]
Ziemian, C. , and Crawn, P., III , 2001, “Computer Aided Decision Support for Fused Deposition Modeling,” Rapid Prototyping J., 7(3), pp. 138–147. [CrossRef]
Panhalkar, N. , Paul, R. , and Anand, S. , 2014, “Increasing Part Accuracy in Additive Manufacturing Processes Using a kd Tree Based Clustered Adaptive Layering,” ASME J. Manuf. Sci. Eng., 136(6), p. 061017. [CrossRef]
Bukkapatnam, S. , and Clark, B. , 2007, “Dynamic Modeling and Monitoring of Contour Crafting—An Extrusion-Based Layered Manufacturing Process,” ASME J. Manuf. Sci. Eng., 129(1), pp. 135–142. [CrossRef]
Fang, T. , Bakhadyrov, I. , Jafari, M. A. , and Alpan, G. , 1998, “Online Detection of Defects in Layered Manufacturing,” International Conference on Robotics and Automation, IEEE, Leuven, May 16–20, pp. 254–259.
Fang, T. , Jafari, M. A. , Danforth, S. C. , and Safari, A. , 2003, “Signature Analysis and Defect Detection in Layered Manufacturing of Ceramic Sensors and Actuators,” Mach. Vision Appl., 15(2), pp. 63–75. [CrossRef]
Cheng, Y. , and Jafari, M. A. , 2008, “Vission-Based Online Process Control in Manufacturing Applications,” IEEE Trans. Auto. Sci. Eng., 5, pp. 140–153. [CrossRef]
Dempster, A. P. , Laird, N. M. , and Rubin, D. B. , 1977, “Maximum Likelihood From Incomplete Data Via the EM Algorithm,” J. R. Stat. Soc. Ser. B (Methodol.), 39(1) pp. 1–38.
Escobar, M. D. , 1994, “Estimating Normal Means With a Dirichlet Process Prior,” J. Am. Stat. Assoc., 89(425), pp. 268–277. [CrossRef]
Weheba, G. , and Sanchez-Marsa, A. , 2006, “Using Response Surface Methodology to Optimize the Stereolithography Process,” Rapid Prototyping J., 12(2), pp. 72–77. [CrossRef]
Kruth, J.-P. , Vandenbroucke, B. , Vaerenbergh, V. J. , and Mercelis, P. , 2005, “Benchmarking of Different SLS/SLM Processes as Rapid Manufacturing Techniques,” International Conference on Polymer and Moulds Innovation (PMI), Gent, Belgium, pp. 1–7.
Moylan, S. , Slotwinski, J. , Cooke, A. , Jurrens, K. , and Donmez, M. A. , 2012, Proposal for a Standardized Test Artifact for Additive Manufacturing Machines and Processes, National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), Gaithersburg, MD.
Cooke, A. , and Soons, J. , 2010, “Variability in the Geometric Accuracy of Additively Manufactured Test Parts,” 21st Annual International Solid Freeform Fabrication Symposium, Austin, TX, pp. 1–12.
Vasudevarao, B. , Natarajan, D. P. , Henderson, M. , and Razdan, A. , 2000, “Sensitivity of RP Surface Finish to Process Parameter Variation,” Proceedings of the Solid Freeform Fabrication, pp. 251–258.
Schmidt, S. R. , and Launsby, R. G. , 1989, Understanding Industrial Designed Experiments, Air Academy Press, Colorado Springs, CO.
Shafer, G. , 1976, A Mathematical Theory of Evidence, Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ.
Ferguson, T. S. , 1983, “Bayesian Density Estimation by Mixtures of Normal Distributions,” Recent Adv. Stat., 24, pp. 287–302.
Rasmussen, C. E. , 2000, “The Infinite Gaussian Mixture Model,” Adv. Neural Inf. Process. Syst., 12(5.2), pp. 554–560.
Beyca, O. F. , 2013, “Sensor-Based Real-Time Process Monitoring for Ultra-Precision Manufacturing Processes With Nonlinearity and Nonstationarity,” Ph.D. dissertation, Oklahoma State University, Stillwater, OK.
Basir, O. , and Yuan, X. , 2007, “Engine Fault Diagnosis Based on Multi-Sensor Information Fusion Using Dempster–Shafer Evidence Theory,” Inf. Fusion, 8(4), pp. 379–386. [CrossRef]
Yang, B.-S. , and Kim, K. J. , 2006, “Application of Dempster–Shafer Theory in Fault Diagnosis of Induction Motors Using Vibration and Current Signals,” Mech. Syst. Signal Process., 20(2), pp. 403–420. [CrossRef]
Parikh, C. R. , Pont, M. J. , and Barrie Jones, N. , 2001, “Application of Dempster–Shafer Theory in Condition Monitoring Applications: A Case Study,” Pattern Recognit. Lett., 22(6–7), pp. 777–785. [CrossRef]
McCulloch, W. S. , and Pitts, W. , 1943, “A Logical Calculus of the Ideas Immanent in Nervous Activity,” Bull. Math. Biophys., 5(4), pp. 115–133. [CrossRef]
Powers, D. M. , 2011, “Evaluation: From Precision, Recall and F-Measure to ROC, Informedness, Markedness and Correlation,” Technical Report No. SIE-07-001.
John, G. H. , and Langley, P. , 1995, “Estimating Continuous Distributions in Bayesian Classifiers,” Proceedings of the Eleventh Conference on Uncertainty in Artificial Intelligence, Morgan Kaufmann Publishers, San Francisco, CA, pp. 338–345.
Lachenbruch, P. A. , 1975, “Discriminant Analysis,” “Encyclopedia of Statistical Sciences,” John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York.
Cortes, C. , and Vapnik, V. , 1995, “Support-Vector Networks,” Mach. Learn., 20(3), pp. 273–297.
Specht, D. F. , 1990, “Probabilistic Neural Networks,” Neural Networks, 3(1), pp. 109–118. [CrossRef]
Hagan, M. T. , Demuth, H. B. , and Beale, M. , 1997, Neural Network Design, PWS Publishing, Boston, MA.


Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 1

Two parts made under identical FFF process conditions yet showing markedly different results. The part on the left was made from an ABS filament which was briefly exposed to light machine oil and thus attracted dirt due to static activity. The part on the right was made from unaffected ABS filament.

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 2

(a) Schematic of the FFF process. (b) Schematic of the FFF setup instrumented with multiple in situ sensors used in this work for measuring process conditions in real-time (the instrumented setup is shown in Fig. 5).

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 3

Summary of the research approach integrating experimental tests, sensor data, and DP modeling for real-time monitoring of FFF process

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 4

Test part resembling the NAS 979 standard part used for experimental trials (note: dimensions are in inches)

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 5

Heterogeneous sensor array for real-time monitoring of FFF process. (a) Noncontact IR temperature sensor for measuring meltpool temperature, borescope camera for real-time video capture capability, and thermocouple to measure extruder temperature. (b) MEMS accelerometer to measure extruder vibration. (c) MEMS accelerometer to measure table vibration, and thermocouples (×4) to measure table temperature.

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 6

Diagram showing the average surface roughness (Ra, μm) for each of the thirteen TCs tested (averaged over three replications)

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 7

Schematic representation of failure due to nozzle clog at low feed to flow ratio (v)

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 8

(Top) The three observed process states in FFF, demarcated as normal, abnormal, and failure. (Bottom) The transition between normal, abnormal, and failure states is prominently evident from the time series pattern of the noncontact IR temperature sensor.

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 9

The summary of the DP mixture model and ET approach developed in this work for real-time monitoring of process states in FFF

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 10

Histogram with fitted probability density functions of IR sensor data at normal, abnormal, and failure process states. The signal patterns have a non-Gaussian probability density function, which is particularly pronounced for the normal state.

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 11

Comparison of F-scores for various sensor combinations using DP + ET approach. The error bars are one standard deviation (σ) long.

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 12

Comparison of F-scores for the three predefined process states in FFF using high-dimensional DP mixture modeling and our proposed DP + ET approach. The error bars are one standard deviation (σ) long.

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 13

Comparison of F-scores for the three predefined process states in FFF with four widely used classification approaches. The error bars are one standard deviation (σ) long.

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 14

The ten locations on the workpiece where the arithmetic mean surface roughness (Ra) values are measured




Some tools below are only available to our subscribers or users with an online account.

Related Content

Customize your page view by dragging and repositioning the boxes below.

Related Journal Articles
Related eBook Content
Topic Collections

Sorry! You do not have access to this content. For assistance or to subscribe, please contact us:

  • TELEPHONE: 1-800-843-2763 (Toll-free in the USA)
  • EMAIL: asmedigitalcollection@asme.org
Sign In